Skip to Content

If you buy something from the links on this page, we may earn a commission. Why Trust Us?

21 Gifts for Baseball Lovers That Really Swing for the Fences

More than just peanuts and crackerjacks.

Headshot of Cat BowenBy Cat Bowen
homesick wrigley field candle, mash and grape cooperstown distillery doubleday bourbon in a baseball decanter, boston red sox fenway park game used dirt bottle, baseball is my favorite season sweatshirt, baseball ring toss game
Best Products; Homesick, Mash&Grape, Fanatic, Emtizee, Uncommon Goods

I come from a family of baseball fanatics, so I know a thing or two about buying the best gifts for baseball lovers. The amount of Guardians games members of my family attend is sort of wild, even to someone who routinely goes to 15 or more AA games per year. (Major league is fine and all, but do they have $1 beer night? No, they do not.)

When you think of gifts for baseball lovers, you're probably thinking along the lines of tickets and jerseys, and those are great, but there are so many cool options available for baseball lovers from stadium dirt to custom bats, and everything in-between. And none of these gifts will feel like they're coming out of left field. (This will not be my last dad joke.)

I have scoured the internet, spoken with other baseball fans, and even chatted up a few strangers watching spring training at a sports bar to find the very best gifts for baseball lovers.

1
Home Run Derby

UncommonGoods Home Plate Doormat

Home Plate Doormat
1
Home Run Derby

UncommonGoods Home Plate Doormat

$34 at Uncommon Goods

The baseball lover in your life can pretend that they are running to first every time they leave their house, and scoring a run every time they return. This doormat is pretty heavy duty, so it can handle the stomping of boots or sneakers, and the paint is surprisingly long-lasting.

More: Gifts for Golf Lovers

2
Root for the Home Team

Pop Chart Lab Major League Ballparks Scratch-Off Poster

Major League Ballparks Scratch-Off Poster
2
Root for the Home Team

Pop Chart Lab Major League Ballparks Scratch-Off Poster

I love a good scratch-off adventure. National parks, top 100 movies, cocktails to try. All of them are fun. The idea of visiting every major league ballpark feels like just the thing that could really make baseball fans salivate in anticipation. It’s travel, it’s ball games, it’s quality time.

3
Smells Like Spring

Homesick Candles Wrigley Field Candles

Wrigley Field Candles
3
Smells Like Spring

Homesick Candles Wrigley Field Candles

Now 50% Off

Arguably one of the most famous ballfields on planet Earth, Wrigley Field deserves all of the accolades it receives. To put the fragrance of the park in a candle? Genius. Ivy, popcorn, and grass make up this tempting candle's notes. Though, I will say it leans more toward hay than grass, but it's still a great candle.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
4
Right There In Black and White

Sports Illustrated Books ‘The Story of Baseball: In 100 Photographs’

‘The Story of Baseball: In 100 Photographs’
4
Right There In Black and White

Sports Illustrated Books ‘The Story of Baseball: In 100 Photographs’

Now 22% Off

The lure of a big, coffee table book is undeniable. They look great as decor, and they're wonderful reading. A book filled with 100 photographs of the history of baseball is simply lovely. One friend of mine said that this book is like warm cocoa, or the scent of that first hot dog of the season — pure comfort.

5
Drink Up

Cooperstown Distillery Doubleday Bourbon in a Barrel in Baseball Decanter

Doubleday Bourbon in a Barrel in Baseball Decanter
5
Drink Up

Cooperstown Distillery Doubleday Bourbon in a Barrel in Baseball Decanter

I know that the temptation will be to leave this bottle full and never drink its contents because it will become less of a show piece. I can guarantee you as a fan of not only baseball, but also this distillery, that would be a sad thing indeed. Their affordable spirits are heavenly, and it's the Cooperstown distillery. That bottle isn't going anywhere fast.

6
It Exists

MLB Shop Boston Red Sox Fenway Park Game-Used Dirt Bottle

Boston Red Sox Fenway Park Game-Used Dirt Bottle
6
It Exists

MLB Shop Boston Red Sox Fenway Park Game-Used Dirt Bottle

I told you this was a thing. I wasn't kidding. More than one dude told me this was cool. Now, none of them had kids or cats, so I can see how it would be cool for them. But for those with kids or cats? This is not the gift for them. It will be destroyed.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
7
Killing Me

Silver Buffalo ‘The Sandlot’ — ‘Killing Me Smalls’ 16-Ounce Pint Glass

‘The Sandlot’ — ‘Killing Me Smalls’ 16-Ounce Pint Glass
7
Killing Me

Silver Buffalo ‘The Sandlot’ — ‘Killing Me Smalls’ 16-Ounce Pint Glass

You don't even need to be a baseball lover to appreciate this gift. The Sandlot is one of the most iconic films of the 1990s. I don't know a single person in their 30s who has never once said to another person, “You’re killing me, Smalls!” This is the adult way to celebrate the film and baseball, but could easily hold any beverage.

8
Take the Chill Off

Etsy ‘Baseball is my Favorite Season’ Sweatshirt

‘Baseball is my Favorite Season’ Sweatshirt
8
Take the Chill Off

Etsy ‘Baseball is my Favorite Season’ Sweatshirt

Baseball might be your favorite season, but with much of it falling in spring and fall, it gets a bit chilly! Warm up at the game with a cute sweatshirt in soft, combed jersey. It comes in multiple sizes and colors, so you can get one for every fan in your family.

9
Time to Compete

Uncommon Goods Baseball Ring Toss Game

Baseball Ring Toss Game
9
Time to Compete

Uncommon Goods Baseball Ring Toss Game

This game is harder than you think, and will be even harder if you've hit the bourbon in the baseball decanter. That being said, it's as much of a piece of art as it is a game, and will look great hanging on your wall in your living room or den.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
10
Personal Pitch

JCSDesigns Personalized Mini Baseball Bat

Personalized Mini Baseball Bat
10
Personal Pitch

JCSDesigns Personalized Mini Baseball Bat

Your little slugger will love this personalized mini baseball bat, and display it proudly. I love this gift especially for when their little league career is coming to a close as a reminder of all of the fun that they had when they were playing the game.

11
Ball Gulls

San Francisco Seagull Classic T-Shirt

San Francisco Seagull Classic T-Shirt
11
Ball Gulls

San Francisco Seagull Classic T-Shirt

I had never heard of this before our copy editor explained it to me, and now I want nothing more than to go to Oracle Park and watch the seagulls descend upon the masses during the late stages of the game, and that's saying something — as I live on a bay and routinely rue the day those birds first graced this earth.

12
Extended Play Time

SPARK CATCH Light-Up Baseball (Switch Version)

Light-Up Baseball (Switch Version)
12
Extended Play Time

SPARK CATCH Light-Up Baseball (Switch Version)

Now 21% Off

Even glowing in the dark does not help my inability to hit or catch a ball, no matter the time of day. However, kids love playing ball and catch during twilight or at night, and this exciting, regulation-size baseball allows them to do that with a bit more ease and a lot of pizazz.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
13
For The Players

Etsy Custom Gatorade Bottles

Custom Gatorade Bottles
13
For The Players

Etsy Custom Gatorade Bottles

This specific Gatorade bottle is pretty much the go-to for all kids playing sports, so why not jazz it up a bit with their name? If you want to make it even more fun, personalize it with whatever nickname they go by while playing. Although mine would probably read “stick to spectating.” Do you think they could fit that on the bottle?

14
Useful and Easy

Ozueccr Hard Hat Case for Baseball Caps

Hard Hat Case for Baseball Caps
14
Useful and Easy

Ozueccr Hard Hat Case for Baseball Caps

Sometimes the best gift is the most useful gift. A hard case for baseball hats that holds five hats and can be stacked with other hat boxes, placed in a suitcase, or held on a shelf. It's a safe place for all of your favorite hats, protecting them from insects, moisture, or from being crushed.

15
Baseball Pinball

International Playthings Game Zone Super Stadium Baseball Game

Game Zone Super Stadium Baseball Game
15
Baseball Pinball

International Playthings Game Zone Super Stadium Baseball Game

The one baseball game I can win, it’s a bit like pinball, but there’s more happening. Surprisingly, the game set is very sturdy, and can handle a lot of play without getting too worn. Each of the little characters are quirky and detailed, and it’s really a good time watching kids play such an analog game.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
16
Ready to Frame

Etsy Custom Watercolor Baseball Stadium

Custom Watercolor Baseball Stadium
16
Ready to Frame

Etsy Custom Watercolor Baseball Stadium

Not all baseball art is created equally. Some of it is plain old cheesy. Not this custom watercolor painting. All you do is fill in what you want and in what colors, and the artist creates a beautiful piece of artwork for your home. The frame is not included.

17
Don't Strike Out

Across the Board Maple Baseball Game

Maple Baseball Game
17
Don't Strike Out

Across the Board Maple Baseball Game

I am picturing this on top of the coffee table book. It's a game, it's a curated piece of art, and it's something to talk about and even break the ice when people come to your house. A simple dice game in simple but gorgeous etched maple wood.

18
Send With Peanuts

Etsy Cracker Jack Print

Cracker Jack Print
18
Send With Peanuts

Etsy Cracker Jack Print

Need a last-minute gift? A high-resolution, high-quality, downloadable print is the best way to go for a baseball lover that isn't a digital gift card. It shows that you put thought into it, and, come on, Cracker Jack? The best of baseball.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
19
Quick and Easy

MLB Shop Gift Card

MLB Shop Gift Card
19
Quick and Easy

MLB Shop Gift Card

Your giftee can choose what they love the best. This is a wonderful gift for a coworker, for a baseball prize, or that person who loves baseball, but seems to have everything already. It's simple, easy, and delivered digitally, making it a great last-minute gift for baseball lovers.

20
On the Rocks

Uncommon Goods Vintage MLB Park Map Glass

Vintage MLB Park Map Glass
20
On the Rocks

Uncommon Goods Vintage MLB Park Map Glass

Need a place to pour that bourbon? How about a rocks glass that is etched with a vintage MLB map? A classic glass made with a hefty bottom, it harkens back to the days immortalized in Mad Men when bourbon or brandy was served in the office.

Headshot of Cat Bowen
Cat Bowen
Parenting Editor

Cat Bowen has been writing about all things parenting for well over a decade. She spends her days researching, reviewing, and testing everything from strollers to breast pumps to changing tables. Her work has been featured in Romper, Bustle, and franchised across dozens of media outlets. In her spare time she loves volunteering at her kids' schools, reading everything she can get her hands on, running, and cooking for her family.

Watch Next
 
preview for HDM All sections playlist - Best Products

Father's Day

beeropoly beer game

The Best Gifts for Beer Lovers

gifts for whiskey lovers

The 30 Best Whiskey Gifts to Give This Season

astroai digital infrared thermometer 550, igloo overland 72 qt ice chest cooler, new philips avance xxl digital twin turbostar airfryer, wireless charging station, soundcore space q45 over ear headphones

20 Father's Day Gifts from Walmart

pizzeria pronto stovetop pizza oven, analog electric smoker with 3 smoking racks, kindle 2022 release, nordictrack 50 lb iselect adjustable dumbbells

81 Best Father’s Day Gifts to Impress Dad

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Logo
twitter icon
youtube icon
facebook icon
instagram icon
pinterest icon
Hearst Lifestyle and Design Group - A Part of Hearst Digital Media

A Part of Hearst Digital Media

We may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.

©2023 Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Privacy NoticeCA Notice at CollectionYour CA Privacy Rights/Shine the LightDAA Industry Opt OutTerms of UseSite Map