Skip to Content

If you buy something from the links on this page, we may earn a commission. Why Trust Us?

The 8 Best Charcoal Grills Perfect for Any Get-Together

Grab the charcoal — it’s grilling season!

Headshot of Brandon CarteBy Brandon Carte
best products charcoal grill
Best Products; Weber

As much as we love the convenience of a gas-powered grill, there's something to be said about the smoky flavor, extra char, and overall experience of cooking with charcoal.

“In the same way many driving enthusiasts prefer manuals to automatics, there is carnal satisfaction in direct control, higher failure rates, and sky-high potential,” says my colleague Johnny Brayson, the associate home editor at Gear Patrol, a sister site to Best Products. Alongside two other testers, Brayson spent months assembling and testing a new batch of the latest and greatest charcoal grills on the market.

Even though charcoal grills take longer to light and have a bit of a learning curve over propane and natural gas-powered grills, they are more affordable, typically don't have as large of a footprint, and they burn hotter (you can expect maximum temperatures over 1,000 degrees Fahrenheit). They also provide a more prominent smoky flavor to your food.

If you're making the switch and are worried about being a little over your head, don't be! Our backyard grill masters have put together a comprehensive guide to help you get started so you know how to properly stack the charcoals, light them, maintain a consistent temperature, and control airflow.

The Best Charcoal Grills of 2023

  • 1
    Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill

    Best Overall

    Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill

    Shop at Amazon
    Read more
  • 2
    Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

    Best Cart-Style Charcoal Grill

    Weber Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

    Read more
  • 3
    Joe Classic II Charcoal Grill

    Best Kamado

    Kamado Joe Joe Classic II Charcoal Grill

    Read more
  • 4
    Original Kettle Charcoal Grill

    Runner-Up

    Weber Original Kettle Charcoal Grill

    Read more
  • 5
    Jumbo Joe Charcoal Grill

    Best Portable Grill

    Weber Jumbo Joe Charcoal Grill

    Read more

    What to Consider

    To find the best grill for your needs, the first and most important thing you can do is think about what you want to cook.

    “If all you want to do is grill a few hot dogs and hamburgers at the campsite, there’s no sense in getting carried away,” said Popular Mechanics test editor Bradley Ford. "Buy an inexpensive grill and use some common sense in preparing that food...but if you want to, say, move on to grilling seafood or smoking brisket, you’re going to need a grill that has the capacity to take you where you want to go."

    Size

    When shopping for a charcoal grill, pay attention to the size of its cooking surface. If you have several mouths to feed, we recommend something with a rectangular cooking surface, but for the occasional griller, a 22-inch kettle should provide plenty of room to feed four (enough for a dozen burger patties). A good rule of thumb is to have at least 72 square inches of cooking space per person.

    Style

    If you're in the market for a charcoal grill, you'll find a variety of styles to choose from, such as kettle, barrel, and kamado grills. While kettle grills offer a relatively small circular cooking surface, they can be a great fit for small families and typically offer buyers a cheaper price point.

    For feeding larger groups, you may want to consider a barrel-style grill which provides more space. Barrel-style grills can accommodate taller proteins such as poultry or beef roasts. On the other hand, kamado grills like the Kamado Joe Classic II Charcoal Grill are constructed with thick ceramic walls that provide superior insulation and can be used for both grilling and smoking, but they have much steeper price points.

    Charcoal grills also vary in their grill grates. Some grills come with cast-iron grates, which hold heat well and create impressive sear marks, while others come with stainless steel grates, which are more affordable and easier to clean and do not require seasoning. Not sure what to opt for? The experts at Amazing Ribs have you covered.

    Warranty

    Although most warranties won't cover misuse or accidental damage, a generous warranty adds some peace of mind when investing in a new grill. We awarded bonus points to brands that offer beyond the standard 1-year warranty. Weber even backs its grills' bowl and lid for a decade.

    How We Chose

    When selecting our top picks, we made sure to include grills of multiple shapes and sizes to account for your space and how many mouths you need to feed. In order to find the best charcoal grills, we did hundreds of hours of research to narrow down the list. We sifted through consumer and editorial reviews at sites such as AmazingRibs.com, CNET, and Insider, and these picks also come recommended from our test teams across multiple Hearst brands including Good Housekeeping, Popular Mechanics, and Gear Patrol.

    Our test team has spent decades testing grills — both gas and charcoal — and various styles of grills — flattop, kettle, barrel, and kamado. We tested grills with different grates and grilled all sorts of proteins— from swordfish to lobster, burgers, sausage, and of course steaks. We also cooked bone-in-chicken and veggie skewers. Popular Mechanics' test editor and grill expert, Bradley Ford rolled a few of our recommended portable grills to sporting events and even grilled in a blizzard.

    We're confident you'll find a grill that suits your needs, budget, and grilling experience. So, shop one of our expert-approved picks below for your tastiest summer yet.

    1
    Best Overall

    Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill

    Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill
    1
    Best Overall

    Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill

    $219 at Amazon$219 at Home Depot$220 at farmandfleet.com
    Pros
    • Offers grillers a convenient ash catch
    • Available in 3 different colors
    • You can add more coal without removing the grate
    • Has a lid hook to keep its lid off the ground
    Cons
    • The built-in thermometer isn’t very accurate

    Weber's iconic 22-inch Kettle grill has been around for more than 70 years and this premium variant adds a few upgrades to make it even better. For starters, there are hooks on its side handles for hanging your tongs and spatula, and it's equipped with a hinged heavy-gauge steel grill grate to add coal.

    But the biggest upgrade is its ash catch, which is an enclosed receptacle at its bottom that captures and holds ash so it won't blow around — eliminating any concern you may have about stray embers. It also makes cleanup much less messy and a lot easier.

    Setup for this charcoal grill takes less than 15 minutes and although its construction is simple, the materials are durable and are built to last. The Weber's porcelain-enameled lid measures in at 7.5 inches tall — giving grillers plenty of room to cook tall items such as beer-can chicken, tomahawk steaks, or even a turkey. The seal between the lid and body is strong and tight, so we're confident it can consistently maintain temperatures and keep smoke in.

    Testers at Wirecutter said the Weber was “the best and most hassle-free grill” they’ve used. “From burgers to chicken to slow-smoked ribs, this Weber model’s time-tested design produces great results—at a terrific price," said senior staff writer Tim Heffernan.

    The Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill is available in black, copper, crimson, or green.

    Key Specs

    Cooking Surface Size363 sq. in.
    Overall Dimensions22.5"D x 22.5"W x 27"H
    Grate MaterialSteel
    Weight37 lbs.
    2
    Best Cart-Style Charcoal Grill

    Weber Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

    Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill
    2
    Best Cart-Style Charcoal Grill

    Weber Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill

    Pros
    • Equipped with a useful propane ignition
    • Easy to keep clean
    • Has a bin for storing charcoal
    Cons
    • Expensive in comparison to similarly shaped charcoal grills

    The Performer Deluxe Charcoal Grill will help any grill master take their grilling to the next level. It’s a more feature-filled take on Weber’s 22-inch Original Kettle grill, but rather than being atop a tripod, it’s built on a wheeled cart and offers grillers a convenient workstation and hooks to hang their favorite tools. There’s even a cook timer built right into the cart, too.

    Even better, the grill is equipped with a “Touch-N-Go” gas ignition for instantly lighting charcoal using a small burner located under the coal grate.

    This charcoal grill provides 363 square inches of cooking space (enough room to cook for a family of 6 or roughly 13 burgers). Its hinged grate allows for easy access to replenish charcoal, and there are two charcoal baskets to allow you to utilize direct or indirect heat with ease.

    Our favorite thing about the Weber is its versatility. There's a wide array of accessories from a pizza stone to a wok, a steamer, a griddle, and more you can purchase to make the most of the Weber.

    Despite the grill's steep price, if you're looking for a cart-style grill, the Performer Deluxe can't be beat. It's durable, easy to clean, and offers a great warranty that covers the bowl and lid for a decade, the cleaning system for five years, and all other parts for two years.

    Key Specs

    Cooking Surface Size363 sq. in.
    Overall Dimensions8"D x 48"W x 43.5"H
    Grate MaterialSteel
    Weight91 lbs.
    3
    Best Kamado

    Kamado Joe Joe Classic II Charcoal Grill

    Joe Classic II Charcoal Grill
    3
    Best Kamado

    Kamado Joe Joe Classic II Charcoal Grill

    Pros
    • Limited lifetime warranty on ceramic parts; 5-year on all metal and cast-iron parts
    • Better-than-average heat retention
    • Has a cushioned seal to prevent slamming of its lid
    Cons
    • Heavy and hard to move despite being on casters

    The Joe Classic II is a premium ceramic egg-shaped cooker. In case you’re unfamiliar, kamado grills originated about 3,000 years ago in Japan and they’re similar in concept to Indian tandoors. They deliver outstanding insulation, so they retain heat incredibly well, lock in moisture, and don’t need a lot of charcoal or oxygen.

    The Classic II, which also doubles as a smoker, comes with a robust and sturdy frame with locking wheels, twin side tables, an ash tool to aid in the cleanup process, and multiple grates.

    The grill heats up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit in less than 10 minutes. It offers users incredible temperature control and is an outstanding choice for people who want to invest in a grill that can sear, smoke, bake, and roast food. Since it reaches temperatures above 600 degrees, we can’t recommend it enough for making pizza.

    It has an easy-to-read thermometer on its front, a rust-resistant aluminum top vent, and a useful spring-loaded hinge that makes it easy to lift and close the lid. Besides its steep price, our biggest complaint about the Joe Classic II is its smaller-than-average cooking surface. It’s also worth mentioning that it weighs approximately 250 pounds when fully assembled. As long as you don’t drop it, the Joe Classic II will last for years.

    Key Specs

    Cooking Surface Size256 sq. in.
    Overall Dimensions26.4"D x 26.4"W x 36"H
    Grate MaterialCast iron
    Weight250 lbs.
    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
    4
    Runner-Up

    Weber Original Kettle Charcoal Grill

    Original Kettle Charcoal Grill
    4
    Runner-Up

    Weber Original Kettle Charcoal Grill

    Now 10% Off
    Pros
    • Offers a great balance between price, durability, and performance
    • Weber provides outstanding customer service and backs its products by a generous warranty
    Cons
    • Lacks the easier-to-clean ash catch as the “premium” model

    For those on a limited budget, this 22-inch charcoal grill is made with the same enameled steel as the Premium version we previously mentioned, and offers the same 363-inch cooking space, but it costs about $80 less.

    The biggest difference between the two is this one lacks the convenient detachable ash catcher, meaning ash is more likely to blow around while you're cooking. Even so, the Original Kettle Charcoal Grill is an impressive grill that may be simple in design, but delivers even heat distribution and a one-touch cleaning system that sweeps the ash from inside the bottom of the kettle.

    We think the Original Kettle grill from Weber offers the best balance between affordability, durability, and performance. And although you can save even more dough by opting for a smaller 18-inch model, we think you should opt for the 22-incher so you can grill larger cuts of meat such as pork shoulder or brisket.

    Key Specs

    Cooking Surface Size363 sq. in.
    Overall Dimensions25"D x 25"W x 39.5"H
    Grate MaterialSteel
    Weight37 lbs.
    5
    Best Portable Grill

    Weber Jumbo Joe Charcoal Grill

    Jumbo Joe Charcoal Grill
    5
    Best Portable Grill

    Weber Jumbo Joe Charcoal Grill

    Pros
    • Can accommodates seven burgers or a full chicken
    • Its swivel arm holds the grill together for transport and doubles as a lid holder while grilling
    Cons
    • There isn't an official protective cover for the Jumbo Joe

    The Weber Jumbo Joe is essentially what you'd get if you'd take a shrink ray to the Weber Kettle Charcoal Grill we previously mentioned.

    At 18 inches wide, the Jumbo Joe is a tad larger than the 14-inch wide Smokey Joe and it comes equipped with two adjustable vents in the lid and firebox — which you'll definitely want to adjust the temperature and keep your coals lit. The Smokey Joe has just one, so it's easier for the coals to extinguish while you're grilling.

    We appreciated the inclusion of an aluminum dish under its bottom that serves as an ash catcher. It also has a unique lid lock system that lets you lock down its lid while moving the grill from place to place. The grill takes less than 5 minutes to install, it is solidly constructed and we're confident it will withstand accidental drops during transport.

    Whether you want to take it to the beach or tailgating, the Jumbo Joe has your back. With its generously sized 240-square-inch cooking surface, it's large enough to cook a whole chicken or a full rack of baby back ribs, but it weighs just 20 pounds and can easily be stowed in the trunk of a vehicle.

    Key Specs

    Cooking Surface Size240 sq. in.
    Overall Dimensions19.75"D x 20.5"W x 19.75"H
    Grate MaterialChrome-Plated Steel
    Weight21 lbs.
    6
    Best Budget

    Nexgrill Cart-Style Charcoal Grill

    Cart-Style Charcoal Grill
    6
    Best Budget

    Nexgrill Cart-Style Charcoal Grill

    Pros
    • Ample grilling space for the price
    • Side table comes in handy
    • Compact
    Cons
    • Isn’t as durable as the competition and is only backed by a 1-year warranty

    For those in search of a no-frills grill that's affordable, convenient, and easy to use you can't go wrong with the Nexgrill Cart Grill.

    Although it doesn’t have the bells and whistles of other more expensive charcoal grills, it’s sturdy, comes with a convenient side shelf, and packs cast-iron grates that are perfect for searing and retaining heat. Since they’re coated with porcelain enamel, you don’t have to spend time seasoning them, either!

    "It’s got all the features needed for good grilling and entry-level smoking," said Johnny Brayson, the associate home editor at Best Products’ sister site Gear Patrol.

    Case in point? The charcoal tray's rack provides the ash with someplace to fall to keep messes and pesky ash down to a minimum. You can also easily move the coals closer to or further from the food thanks to its adjustable grates, which is another nice touch.

    Key Specs

    Cooking Surface Size413 sq. in.
    Overall Dimensions24.75"D x 36"W x 42.25"H
    Grate MaterialPorcelain cast iron
    Weight41 lbs.
    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
    7
    Packed With Features

    Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800 Digital Charcoal Grill, Griddle, and Smoker

    Gravity Series 800 Digital Charcoal Grill, Griddle, and Smoker
    7
    Packed With Features

    Masterbuilt Gravity Series 800 Digital Charcoal Grill, Griddle, and Smoker

    Pros
    • Onboard computer offers precision grilling
    • Self-feeding design holds enough fuel for 12-15 hours of grilling/smoking
    Cons
    • Difficult to assemble

    The full-sized cart-style grill from Masterbuilt is the grill to buy if you’re feeding a crowd. There’s an 800-square-inch cooking surface with enough space to grill six racks of ribs, 57 sausages, or three dozen burgers. It’s a good choice for folks looking for a “set-and-forget it” design since it cooks more like a pellet smoker with its electronic temperature controls and coal hopper. Since the grill has Wi-Fi, you can monitor and regulate temperature remotely in real time.

    We would have liked to see a higher peak temperature — this one has a range of just 150 to 700 degrees Fahrenheit, but our tester had no trouble smoking a small brisket to perfection, grilling burgers, and cooking a good-sized chicken on the racks above the grill grates away from the heat.

    It's worth mentioning that testers at both Gear Patrol and CNET remarked that the overall construction of the Gravity Series grills is questionable with its plastic parts and lack of weather resistance, but our tester said the convenience makes it worth it.

    “Due to the vertical hopper, the charcoal flows down as it burns, with the ash simply falling into a bucket at the bottom. Just open a door and empty the bucket — it’s that easy,” said Popular Mechanics test editor Bradley Ford.

    Key Specs

    Cooking Surface Size800 sq. in.
    Overall Dimensions30.5"D x 50.9"W x 55.1"H
    Grate MaterialCast iron
    Weight204 lbs.
    Pros
    • Heats up quickly
    • Outstanding weather resistance
    • Backed by a 20-year limited warranty
    Cons
    • Assembly instructions are confusing at times

    The Original PK grill and smoker is a compact cart-style grill perfect for any patio or small backyard. Although it has a smaller cooking surface than other charcoal grills on the market, its compact design makes it easy to store or take traveling with you.

    The grill is equipped with four adjustable vents, it has a unique hinged lid that opens from the left (rather than the back like most propane-powered grills, and it offers outstanding heat retention and weather resistance.

    Testers at Gear Patrol and Insider sang praises of the grill's thick, cast-aluminum build, cast-aluminum lugs and legs, and nickel-plated steel grates. The grill is rustproof and PK Grills backs it by a 20-year warranty. So, you can be confident it will last for years to come.

    “The Original PK grill helped grilling-rookie me create dishes that you’d expect from a pro,” said tester Caitlyn Shaw from Gear Patrol, a sister site to Best Products. "It's compact, easy to use, heats up quickly, and has plenty of vents to offer control over cooking temperature and time. Even if it does take a little more time than expected to set up, that time is well worth the grilled and smoked meats and veggies the grill can create."

    Key Specs

    Cooking Surface Size316 sq. in.
    Overall Dimensions16"D x 42.8"W x 37.4"H
    Grate MaterialSteel
    Weight60 lbs.
    Headshot of Brandon Carte
    Brandon Carte
    Senior Electronics Editor

    Brandon Carte has been covering technology at BestProducts.com since 2017, where he's been writing about the latest gadgets, appliances, and scouring the internet for the products that make life easier. His reporting has been featured on TopTenReviews.com, Good Housekeeping and USA Today. When he's not researching washing machines or testing robot vacuums, you can find him at concerts, swimming laps, or at the movies. He thinks smartphones are too big, prefers MP3s to Spotify, and misses his iPhone’s headphone jack.

    Watch Next
     
    preview for HDM All sections playlist - Best Products

    Large Appliances

    lg quadwash pro dishwasher

    LG QuadWash Pro Review: This Dishwasher Delivers

    man pushing lawn mower

    The 11 Best Lawn Mowers for a Yard of Any Size

    couple putting dishes into dishwasher

    The Best Dishwashers for a Thorough Clean

    woman toweling off in bathroom

    Best Towel Warmers for Toasty, Post-Shower Luxury

    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
    Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
    Logo
    twitter icon
    youtube icon
    facebook icon
    instagram icon
    pinterest icon
    Hearst Lifestyle and Design Group - A Part of Hearst Digital Media

    A Part of Hearst Digital Media

    We may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.

    ©2023 Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

    Privacy NoticeCA Notice at CollectionYour CA Privacy Rights/Shine the LightDAA Industry Opt OutTerms of UseSite Map