If you buy something from the links on this page, we may earn a commission. Why Trust Us?
The 8 Best Charcoal Grills Perfect for Any Get-Together
Grab the charcoal — it’s grilling season!

As much as we love the convenience of a gas-powered grill, there's something to be said about the smoky flavor, extra char, and overall experience of cooking with charcoal.
“In the same way many driving enthusiasts prefer manuals to automatics, there is carnal satisfaction in direct control, higher failure rates, and sky-high potential,” says my colleague Johnny Brayson, the associate home editor at Gear Patrol, a sister site to Best Products. Alongside two other testers, Brayson spent months assembling and testing a new batch of the latest and greatest charcoal grills on the market.
Even though charcoal grills take longer to light and have a bit of a learning curve over propane and natural gas-powered grills, they are more affordable, typically don't have as large of a footprint, and they burn hotter (you can expect maximum temperatures over 1,000 degrees Fahrenheit). They also provide a more prominent smoky flavor to your food.
If you're making the switch and are worried about being a little over your head, don't be! Our backyard grill masters have put together a comprehensive guide to help you get started so you know how to properly stack the charcoals, light them, maintain a consistent temperature, and control airflow.
The Best Charcoal Grills of 2023
What to Consider
To find the best grill for your needs, the first and most important thing you can do is think about what you want to cook.
“If all you want to do is grill a few hot dogs and hamburgers at the campsite, there’s no sense in getting carried away,” said Popular Mechanics test editor Bradley Ford. "Buy an inexpensive grill and use some common sense in preparing that food...but if you want to, say, move on to grilling seafood or smoking brisket, you’re going to need a grill that has the capacity to take you where you want to go."
Size
When shopping for a charcoal grill, pay attention to the size of its cooking surface. If you have several mouths to feed, we recommend something with a rectangular cooking surface, but for the occasional griller, a 22-inch kettle should provide plenty of room to feed four (enough for a dozen burger patties). A good rule of thumb is to have at least 72 square inches of cooking space per person.
Style
If you're in the market for a charcoal grill, you'll find a variety of styles to choose from, such as kettle, barrel, and kamado grills. While kettle grills offer a relatively small circular cooking surface, they can be a great fit for small families and typically offer buyers a cheaper price point.
For feeding larger groups, you may want to consider a barrel-style grill which provides more space. Barrel-style grills can accommodate taller proteins such as poultry or beef roasts. On the other hand, kamado grills like the Kamado Joe Classic II Charcoal Grill are constructed with thick ceramic walls that provide superior insulation and can be used for both grilling and smoking, but they have much steeper price points.
Charcoal grills also vary in their grill grates. Some grills come with cast-iron grates, which hold heat well and create impressive sear marks, while others come with stainless steel grates, which are more affordable and easier to clean and do not require seasoning. Not sure what to opt for? The experts at Amazing Ribs have you covered.
Warranty
Although most warranties won't cover misuse or accidental damage, a generous warranty adds some peace of mind when investing in a new grill. We awarded bonus points to brands that offer beyond the standard 1-year warranty. Weber even backs its grills' bowl and lid for a decade.
How We Chose
When selecting our top picks, we made sure to include grills of multiple shapes and sizes to account for your space and how many mouths you need to feed. In order to find the best charcoal grills, we did hundreds of hours of research to narrow down the list. We sifted through consumer and editorial reviews at sites such as AmazingRibs.com, CNET, and Insider, and these picks also come recommended from our test teams across multiple Hearst brands including Good Housekeeping, Popular Mechanics, and Gear Patrol.
Our test team has spent decades testing grills — both gas and charcoal — and various styles of grills — flattop, kettle, barrel, and kamado. We tested grills with different grates and grilled all sorts of proteins— from swordfish to lobster, burgers, sausage, and of course steaks. We also cooked bone-in-chicken and veggie skewers. Popular Mechanics' test editor and grill expert, Bradley Ford rolled a few of our recommended portable grills to sporting events and even grilled in a blizzard.
We're confident you'll find a grill that suits your needs, budget, and grilling experience. So, shop one of our expert-approved picks below for your tastiest summer yet.
Brandon Carte has been covering technology at BestProducts.com since 2017, where he's been writing about the latest gadgets, appliances, and scouring the internet for the products that make life easier. His reporting has been featured on TopTenReviews.com, Good Housekeeping and USA Today. When he's not researching washing machines or testing robot vacuums, you can find him at concerts, swimming laps, or at the movies. He thinks smartphones are too big, prefers MP3s to Spotify, and misses his iPhone’s headphone jack.
Watch Next


LG QuadWash Pro Review: This Dishwasher Delivers

The 11 Best Lawn Mowers for a Yard of Any Size

The Best Dishwashers for a Thorough Clean

Best Towel Warmers for Toasty, Post-Shower Luxury